Thanks to Sarah for:

Perverted Fail?
"No Check Accept"
Presidential News Article Gone Wrong
Good Thing Spelling Isn't One Of The Ten...
Craft Gone Wrong
English Fail Blog Surpasses One Million ...
Graffiti Fail
Are You Smarter Than A Fifth Grader?
FAIL PEN
This Is Mixed Up
Jewelry Fail
Christmas Socks Fail
Parking Lot Sign Fail
Spring Concert Fail

Eh, it’s probably meant to appear charming and rural. Bleh.
I agree. It’s supposed to be cutesy.
Right. It’s a common intentional colloquial misspelling.
Isn’t a “punkin” a cute little kid? I don’t see any kids for sale (but 39 cents per pound WOULD be a bargain).
I agree – a young John Lydon, maybe?
So the question is — do you still fail if you misspell intentionally in an effort to be charming?
Answer — yes, yes, yes, a thousand times yes. Even more so.
If you’re a tard who made a grammatical mistake, you’re still firing on more cylinders than the uber-tard who did it on purpose.
Isn’t that the entire concept behind I Can Has Cheezburger?
That doesn’t count. Those are kitties. Kitties can’t spell for beans.
This is an obvious spelling fail but you would be surprised how prevalent people say punkins down here in the deep south.
argh my ex used to all ways spell it punkin, whenever I corrected him he’d just ignore it
Now that I think about it, I think he pronounced it that way too… what the HELL was I doing!?
all ways? ha fail